How to Heal Over-Exfoliated Skin (And Why You Might Not Be “Sensitive”)

Written By sally parks

If your skin constantly feels red, tight, flaky, or irritated—especially after applying products you used to love—you might not be “sensitive.” You might just have a stripped skin barrier. And the good news? You can fix it.

Let’s dive into what your barrier actually is, how it gets damaged, and what you can do to rebuild it.

What Is Your Skin Barrier?

Your skin barrier—also called the “acid mantle”—is a thin layer made of lipids, ceramides, and sweat that keeps moisture in and bad stuff (like allergens and bacteria) out. It’s your skin’s first line of defense and plays a huge role in keeping it hydrated, calm, and clear. This barrier also relies on a slightly acidic pH, ideally between 4.7 and 5.5. That acidity keeps your skin’s microbiome balanced and prevents the overgrowth of harmful bacteria.

How Barriers Get Damaged

Even the most well-meaning routines can wreck your barrier. Common culprits include:

  • Over-exfoliating with AHAs, BHAs, scrubs, or retinoids (especially when used daily or combined without guidance)

  • Harsh cleansers with sulfates or high pH. Even so-called “neutral” cleansers like Cetaphil can be problematic—they often use sodium lauryl sulfate, strip away natural oils, and don’t contain any replenishing ingredients to help your skin bounce back. A truly barrier-safe cleanser should cleanse gently and leave your skin feeling hydrated, not squeaky.

  • Too many active ingredients Mixing acids, retinoids, vitamin C, and exfoliants without a plan is a recipe for irritation. Retinol is one of the most over-used products that we see with new clients. “More is better” is not the case with actives. however.

  • Environmental stressors Living in Texas, the heat, intense UV exposure, dry wind, and accompanying sweat buildup, makes your skin work overtime. UV rays alone break down lipids and collagen, weakening the barrier daily.

  • Hot water or frequent cleansing Long, steamy showers and cleansing multiple times a day can strip essential oils and disrupt your skin’s natural pH.

How to Heal Your Barrier: A Simple, Science-Backed Routine

Step 1: Gentle Cleansing

Cleansing shouldn’t make your skin feel squeaky or tight. Choose a pH-balanced, sulfate-free cleanser to remove impurities without stripping essential oils.

Our Top Picks:

Step 2: Hydrate and Soothe

Once clean, your skin needs hydration from water-binding ingredients (like glycerin or hyaluronic acid) and soothing agents to reduce inflammation and rebuild balance.

Our Top Picks:

  • Hale & Hush Hydrate Gel – Lightweight yet powerful. This gel delivers hydration and calming botanicals like hemidesmus and skullcap root.

  • Rhonda Allison Hydra Mist – A hydrating toner packed with anti-inflammatory ingredients like cucumber and borage oil. This (awesome-smelling!) mist is great for all day use as a refresher and even to set make-up!

  • Face Reality Calming Facial Toner – Especially great for acne-prone skin, it soothes with allantoin and D-panthenol.

Step 3: Rebuild the Barrier

Now that your skin is calm and hydrated, you need to lock in moisture and restore lipid content. Look for products with ceramides, peptides, niacinamide, and essential fatty acids.

Our Top Picks:

  • Rhonda Allison Holistic Hydration – Uses plant growth factors, red clover, sodium hyaluronate and root extracts for antioxidant and anti-inflammatory support, hydration, cell rejuvenation and collagen production.

  • Hale & Hush Vital Lipid Lotion – A favorite for those with reactive skin; mimics the skin’s own barrier structure using cholesterol, fatty acids, and ceramides.

  • Face Reality Clearderma Moisturizer – Lightweight but restorative, with antioxidant support and ingredients that help reduce shine without clogging pores.

Reminder: Healthy Skin Is Acidic

That tight, squeaky feeling you might associate with “clean” is actually a red flag. It often means your cleanser or toner is **too alkaline**, stripping your skin’s natural acidic shield.

A properly acidic barrier:

  • Keeps your skin’s microbiome happy

  • Reduces inflammation

  • Speeds up wound healing

  • Enhances product absorption

By choosing pH-balanced products and being thoughtful with actives, you're supporting long-term skin health—not just chasing short-term glow.

Barrier repair isn’t just a trend—it’s essential. Whether your skin is flaky, inflamed, breaking out, or just not behaving like it used to, your skin barrier may be crying out for support.

With a simplified routine and curated products, you can restore calm, balance, and resilience to your skin in just a few weeks.



sally parks
Next

DO YOU HAVE "ORGANIC NAIL POLISH"?